The Psychology of Prestige: Why We Crave What We Can’t Have

There’s a peculiar allure to the unattainable. Whether it’s the limited-edition sneakers that sell out in seconds, the exclusive club with a mile-long waiting list, or the dream job that seems just out of reach, we are inexplicably drawn to what we cannot have.

But why? What is it about scarcity, exclusivity, and prestige that hijacks our desires and compels us to chase the elusive?

Get Abelson's Android App

Click the logo below to download our app from the Google Play Store:

The answer lies deep within the labyrinth of human psychology, a fascinating interplay of social conditioning, evolutionary instincts, and the intoxicating allure of status.

At its core, the craving for prestige is rooted in our evolutionary past. For our ancestors, status wasn’t just about bragging rights; it was a matter of survival. Higher status often meant better access to resources, mates, and protection.

Fast forward to the modern era, and while the stakes may have changed, the wiring remains the same. We are hardwired to associate prestige with survival, even if the “resources” we seek today come in the form of luxury cars, designer handbags, or VIP experiences.

But prestige isn’t just about survival; it’s about identity. In a world where social media has turned every individual into a personal brand, what we possess (or aspire to possess) becomes a reflection of who we are.

The limited-edition watch or the invitation-only event isn’t just an object or an experience; it’s a symbol of our uniqueness, our taste, and our place in the social hierarchy. Psychologists call this “signalling theory,” the idea that we use possessions and experiences to communicate our value to others. And when something is rare or exclusive, its signalling power is amplified.

Scarcity, a key ingredient of prestige, plays a particularly potent role in this dynamic. The less available something is, the more our brains perceive it as valuable. This is known as the scarcity heuristic, a mental shortcut that equates rarity with worth.

Marketers and luxury brands have long exploited this principle, creating artificial scarcity to fuel demand. Think of Hermès’ Birkin bags or Tesla’s early Model S releases, products that were not just expensive but deliberately hard to obtain. The result? A frenzy of desire that borders on obsession.

Yet, the psychology of prestige isn’t just about external validation; it’s also deeply tied to our internal sense of achievement. The pursuit of the unattainable challenges us, pushing us to prove our worth to ourselves and others. It’s a high-stakes game where the reward isn’t just the object of desire but the satisfaction of having conquered the unconquerable.

But here’s the twist: the more we attain, the more our desires shift. Psychologists refer to this as the “hedonic treadmill,” the phenomenon where we constantly chase new goals without ever finding lasting satisfaction. Prestige, it seems, is a moving target, one that keeps us perpetually striving, yearning, and dreaming.

So, the next time you find yourself coveting the unattainable, take a moment to ask: Are you chasing the object itself, or the story it tells about who you are?

The psychology of prestige is a mirror, reflecting not just what we want, but why we want it. And in that reflection lies the key to understanding one of the most powerful drivers of human behaviour.

Intrigued? Dive deeper into the fascinating world of human desires and discover what your cravings reveal about you. After all, the most exclusive thing of all might just be self-awareness.

30-Day Free Trial

Enjoy Abelson's Premium content. Cancel anytime

Subscribe now